Ukraine, South Africa, Indonesia and India Among Key Emerging Markets Vulnerable to Currency Crisis, IHS Markit Says
Emerging market currencies that have already seen depreciation this year will continue to be susceptible to balance-of-payment crises, according to the External Vulnerability Index published by business information provider IHS Markit (Nasdaq: INFO). Emerging market currencies have depreciated by approximately 8 percent against the U.S. dollar through end-September 2018.
The Ukrainian hryvnia, the currency identified as the most vulnerable according to IHS Markit, has been under significant pressure since early 2018. However, with the intervention of the National Bank, the hryvnia’s exchange rate has so far only weakened by 0.8 percent this year against the U.S. dollar.
“Ukraine remains vulnerable to adverse external financial conditions owing to its chronic current-account and fiscal deficits, which require external financing; thin cover for imports, usually verging on the three-month mandatory threshold; expensive access to capital markets and very high debt-to-external earnings ratio,” said Nariman Behravesh, chief economist for IHS Markit. “In the past, these weaknesses were exacerbated when external and domestic political instability converged.”
The External Vulnerability Index from IHS Markit ranks 190 countries based on the stability of their currency, using measures such as the current-account balance, external debt exposure, foreign exchange reserves and inflation. Macroeconomic policy prudence and political risk are also factored into the final ranking. Additional elements of the vulnerability score include countries’ foreign exchange systems, the size of foreign direct investment (FDI) inflow and external debt. The External Vulnerability Index score correlates with the rank of a country out of the 190 surveyed: a score of 25 indicates a country’s currency ranks as the 25th most vulnerable.
The South African rand, which has already depreciated 13 percent against the U.S. dollar through September 2018, will continue to be vulnerable, recording a score of 31, with weakness across all index factors except inflation.
Falling in the middle of the index rankings were Indonesia at 74 and India at 81, owing to their high ratios of external debt to foreign exchange earnings. The Indonesian rupiah has depreciated more than 9 percent through end-September, with India’s rupee depreciating just under 12 percent in the same period.
“The least vulnerable emerging markets are China and Russia, owing to their persistent current-account surpluses, low external debt exposure, and ample foreign exchange reserves,” Behravesh said. “However, Russia is far less robust, owing to geopolitical risks and its open borders to capital movements.”
Turkey and Argentina, whose lira and peso have depreciated against the U.S. dollar by 37 and 54 percent in 2018, respectively, rank high on the index. Turkey, with a score of 10, shows danger signs across almost all indicators: high current-account deficit even after accounting for FDI inflows, large external debt exposure, low level of foreign reserves and high inflation. Similarly, Argentina, at 25, shows vulnerabilities across these measures except the current account if we factor in FDI.
Joining Ukraine, Turkey, Argentina, South Africa, Indonesia and India with a score below 100 were Egypt, Romania, Mexico and Colombia. Brazil and the Philippines scored in the low 100s at 106 and 107, respectively.
For more information on the methodology used, or for a list of Emerging Market External Vulnerability Index rankings, click here.