Six Considerations for Sourcing Post-Consumer Recycled Materials
By Andy VanPutte, Senior Supply Chain Management Director, Jabil Packaging Solutions
Originally published on the Jabil Blog
Ask many of the world’s leading brands about their sustainable packaging plans and they will tell you: they aim to make their packaging 100 percent reusable or recyclable by 2025. More specifically, many plan to source post-consumer recycled (PCR) materials—such as resin—to get there. This sentiment is echoed across the entire landscape of food and beverage, as well as personal and home care segments.
In fact, among companies in those segments, nearly half say post-consumer recycled resin is playing a significant role in their sustainable packaging strategies, according to Jabil’s recent study. Consumer packaged goods companies have a strong tendency (64 percent) to incorporate PCR materials as part of their product-level initiatives
While post-consumer recycled resin seems to be the leading option to accomplish sustainability goals in the packaging industry, there are several considerations to make when sourcing the material:
1) How can I be sure my company is using 100 percent post-consumer recycled resin?
There are four main plastics used in packaging: polyethylene (PE), polypropylene (PP), polystyrene (PS) and polyethylene terephthalate (PET). Currently, PET and high-density PE are the most frequently recycled polymers. The infrastructure is built to support the collection of these materials and many CPGs lead initiatives to educate consumers to recycle. PP is readily recyclable but needs more infrastructure and education around the material. Finally, PS is also recyclable as it is extremely tolerant to “re-melting,” but its collection presents difficulties due to its form factor.
Certain plastics are like oil and water—they don’t mix well. The contamination caused by their mixing, or worse yet, the addition of other factors (such as food, dirt, or other contaminants) can render the resins very difficult to reuse. The makeup of the resins can be a big obstacle in the industry’s endeavor to achieve a truly circular economy, which is a critical piece for packaging.
In addition, based on your company’s performance requirements of the product, the mixing of the materials can lead to further complications in achieving goals. Almost 60 percent of European plastics converting companies find it “hard” or “very hard” to reuse plastic scrap due to contamination, according to a European Plastics Converters Association study.
Then how can you ensure 100 percent purity?
The first step is to establish a set of recycled material goals for your product. Then, you need to partner with your supplier to evaluate and understand their sources and supply chain. They must have the appropriate quality controls and tests in place to ensure the material supplied meets your product’s specifications.
Therefore, it is imperative that you have full visibility into your supplier ecosystem and a strong understanding of how the post-consumer recycled resin was sourced, processed and produced.
2) Does the PCR resin comply with regulations?
Not every type of recycled resin works for every use case or complies with applicable regulations.
In the United States, the FDA has guidelines for the use of recycled plastics in food packaging. Specifically, they have three concerns that:
• Contaminants from the recycled material may end up in the food packaging
• Non-regulated post-consumer materials may make their way into food packaging
• Adjuvants in the recycled materials may not comply with food-contact regulations
Europe has more stringent guidelines. Under a regulation set over a decade ago, only “food-contact materials and articles that contain recycled plastic obtained from an authorized recycling process” may be used in the EU.
It is very likely that in the future more industry standards will be developed, and perhaps also government regulation, to ensure the material really is what it should be. Brands once again can partner with governments worldwide to help shape regulation and drive post-consumer materials forward.
Over the long term, this area will become more like medicine or food—when we go to a grocery or drug store, we hardly ever think about whether the medicine or food is “good” or “safe.” We rely on the system in the background which ensures that it is.
3) Where can I find steady sources of high-quality PCR resin?
Finding a steady source of high-quality recycled resin is a difficult endeavor today. Consumers are not yet recycling enough plastic worldwide—which drastically impacts the supply. The reasons vary from geographically different regulations to the additional cost customers must occasionally incur to recycle. Furthermore, while many understand the importance of recycling, many are also confused on how to properly do it.
With such high demand for recycled materials, brands and packaging integrators must treat the sourcing of these resins as a partnership with their supplier, rather than a transactional exchange. Unlike sourcing virgin material, brands, converters and suppliers must work as a team and make the proper investments to build a viable infrastructure. Sometimes, that means launching community initiatives.
PepsiCo, for example, recognizes the importance of bringing all stakeholders together. To support the development of their sustainable packaging, they launched PepsiCo Recycling, an initiative to improve recycling infrastructure and raise awareness on the issue worldwide. With their partnerships through the program, they’ve provided recycling access to 33 million households across 700 communities in the U.S. since 2014, collecting more than 115 million pounds of recyclables.
These types of partnerships and investments can help you reach your sustainable packaging goals while making a big difference for the environment.
4) How can my company contribute to a steadier supply of recycled materials?
While long-term partnerships and investments into the larger ecosystem will help to ensure a steady supply of post-consumer recycled resins, end-of-life must be addressed at the very beginning with product design. As it stands currently, approximately 30 percent of plastic packaging will never be reused or recycled without fundamental redesign or innovation, according to the World Economic Forum.
The current recycling infrastructure needs an overhaul, but brands can design their packages to optimize recyclability while working within the boundaries of the current infrastructure. This can be accomplished in different ways, such as making components out of a single polymer family, tethering a cap to a bottle or by minimizing how the packaging is assembled so it can be easily separated when necessary.
When designing product packaging, end-of-life must be top-of-mind. Otherwise, your company is contributing to the same problem it’s trying to overcome.
5) What is the best format for post-consumer recycled resin?
Typically, most packaging providers need the raw material to be in a relatively dense form, like the pelletized format of virgin material. Pellets are generally more efficient as the industry is used to handling them, and they do not require extra investment in handling/processing equipment. Recycled packaging that has not been densified or parts that are not reground, are difficult to handle.
“Regrind” typically means that the plastic is in small, irregularly shaped bits, though there can also be the presence of dust and “fines.” Regrind can be re-melted into pellets and then reprocessed yet again into the next product in the full circle. It is important to note: while some materials are tolerant to this repeated melting, others may require different processing in order to be used effectively.
6) How can my company keep all materials out of the waste stream?
Keeping all material out of the waste stream requires a mindset change. Customers don’t have to be your only source for recycled materials. There is another option: post-industrial material. In many ways, post-industrial is another viable source of material that might otherwise be headed for the landfill, while easing many of the technical challenges brands face with PCR materials.
It is easier to acquire post-industrial materials in bigger quantities. Often, it may be scrap or waste that will more readily meet packaging specifications. As an industry, we need to ensure that we reuse or recycle every bit of waste we possibly can. Post-industrial recycled waste is a good short-term solution for a steady supply, while the whole ecosystem finds solutions to overcome the long-term challenges of PCR materials.
It’s clear that all stakeholders in the sustainable packaging ecosystem—from packaging converters and governments to recyclers and consumers—have a role to play in overcoming the environmental issues we are facing today. But if brands are aiming to achieve the public goals they have set for their teams, they’re going to need to be involved heavily in partnering with everyone across the spectrum to source PCR materials, starting by asking these six questions.